Blog · ·
How to Approve Plant Substitutions on Nashville Landscape Projects
Evaluate plant substitutions for Nashville jobs: compare size, screening, spacing, availability, and client approval before releasing the order.
A plant substitution can keep a Nashville landscape project moving, or create a costly mismatch between the approved plan and the installed result.
When a specified plant, size, or quantity is unavailable, do not default to “whatever the nursery has.” Review the substitute against the role the original plant plays in the design: screening, shade, mature size, texture, bloom, site conditions, and the client’s expectations.
For pool builders, landscape firms, and outdoor-living contractors, the goal is simple: keep the install on schedule without compromising what was sold to the client.
Start with the plant’s job, not just its name
The correct substitute is not always the closest-looking plant on a nursery availability list.
Before approving a replacement, identify what the original plant was meant to do on the project.
- Is it creating a privacy screen around a pool or outdoor living area?
- Is it a shade tree intended to make a patio usable in summer?
- Is it a focal-point specimen near an entry, pool, or hardscape feature?
- Is it filling a foundation bed, slope, retaining wall, or narrow planting zone?
- Is it being used for seasonal color, evergreen structure, or erosion control?
Keep the design intent: A substitute should preserve the plant’s function first. Matching the species name matters less than matching the design purpose and the conditions at the site.
For example, if a landscape plan specifies tall evergreen material to screen a neighboring property, replacing it with a flowering shrub of a similar current height may solve an availability issue but fail the privacy objective.
Compare the seven details that matter
When Arboras proposes a substitution, review these details before approving the order.
1. Mature height and width
Check how large the original and replacement plants will become, not only how they look at delivery.
A substitute that grows significantly wider can overcrowd a pool deck, walkway, retaining wall, or foundation planting. One that matures shorter may leave a privacy screen incomplete.
Ask:
- Will it reach the intended screening or shade height?
- Will its mature width fit the planting bed?
- Will the plant need more spacing than the original plan allows?
- Does it change the long-term maintenance requirement?
2. Current size and grade
For B&B trees and large shrubs, current size is often the reason a substitution is proposed.
A 3.5-inch caliper tree may be an appropriate substitute for a specified 4-inch caliper tree in some projects. On a formal entry, high-visibility pool surround, or commercial frontage, the size difference may matter more.
Review:
- Caliper for deciduous trees
- Height and spread for evergreen screening material
- Container size for shrubs, grasses, perennials, and groundcover
- Whether the replacement keeps the planting balanced with surrounding material
If a substitute changes the visual scale of one side of a project, consider adjusting adjacent plant sizes or quantities rather than approving a single mismatched plant.
3. Evergreen, deciduous, flowering, or ornamental role
Do not replace an evergreen screen with a deciduous tree without confirming that seasonal privacy is not important.
Likewise, do not replace a flowering focal tree with a purely functional shade tree if the landscape plan depends on spring interest, fall color, fragrance, or a particular texture.
The substitute should preserve the role the client purchased.
4. Site conditions
A plant that works in one part of Nashville may struggle in another based on sun exposure, drainage, irrigation, soil, wind, and reflected heat from hardscape.
Confirm that the substitute fits:
- Full sun, part shade, or shade
- Wet, average, or dry soil conditions
- Poolside heat and reflected light
- Compact or clay-heavy soils common on many Middle Tennessee sites
- Space near utilities, structures, fences, and hardscape
For site-specific plant-selection guidance, consult University of Tennessee Extension’s landscape resources alongside the project’s planting plan.
5. Spacing and plant count
A larger or smaller replacement can change the spacing math across an entire bed.
If a specified shrub was intended to be planted on 36-inch centers and the substitute matures substantially wider, keeping the original quantity can lead to crowding. If the replacement matures smaller, the same count may leave visible gaps.
Before approval, verify:
- On-center spacing
- Mature spread
- Total quantity needed
- Whether the bed still fills evenly
- Whether the replacement affects neighboring species
This is especially important for privacy rows, mass plantings, foundation beds, and plantings around pool equipment.
6. Availability and lead time
A substitute that fits the design is only useful if it can arrive when the crew needs it.
For Nashville projects, availability can change quickly during spring and fall. Large-caliper B&B trees and mature screening material often need earlier planning than smaller container stock.
Ask the supplier:
- Is the replacement currently available in the quoted size and quantity?
- Has the material been checked before the quote was issued?
- Can it be held if the jobsite is not ready?
- Can the delivery be rescheduled if hardscape, grading, or pool construction shifts?
7. Client and designer approval
A landscape contractor should not assume that a plant substitution is automatically acceptable to the homeowner, landscape architect, or project designer.
Get the proposed substitute in writing with:
- Original specification: Plant name and size
- Replacement: Proposed name and size
- Reason: Why the specified material is unavailable
- Impact: Changes to price, quantity, spacing, or delivery timing
- Sign-off: Approval from the appropriate decision-maker
A clear approval record protects the contractor, keeps the project moving, and prevents disputes after installation.
A simple substitution approval process
Use this five-step process whenever a specified plant is unavailable.
1. Confirm the shortage
Verify that the original plant, size, or quantity is genuinely unavailable for the needed delivery window.
Availability should be checked against current grower inventory, not a static plant list.
2. Request the closest functional match
Ask for a substitute that preserves the original plant’s role in the landscape.
The proposed option should account for mature size, screening value, sun exposure, water needs, texture, and seasonal interest.
3. Review the impact on the plan
Compare the substitute to the original plant and determine whether the rest of the plan needs adjustment.
This may include spacing, quantity, bed layout, price, or expected maintenance.
4. Get written approval
Send the original and proposed line items to the client, designer, or internal project lead.
Do not rely on a verbal approval for a change that affects the appearance, performance, or price of the installed landscape.
5. Release the order only after approval
Once the substitute is approved, the supplier can coordinate the material and delivery with confidence.
This prevents unapproved swaps from arriving on site and gives the crew a clear, install-ready list.
Example: approving a privacy-screen substitution
Consider a Brentwood pool project that specifies 10- to 11-foot B&B Green Giant arborvitae for a backyard privacy screen.
The requested quantity is not available, but 9- to 10-foot material is available now, along with a limited number of 11-foot trees.
Before approving the replacement, the contractor should confirm:
- Whether the reduced height still meets the client’s immediate privacy expectation
- Whether the screen will look even across the planting row
- Whether a mix of sizes is acceptable or whether the delivery should be delayed
- Whether spacing or quantity needs to change
- Whether the homeowner or designer approves the revised material
The right answer may be to use the available size. It may also be to wait, source from another grower, or revise the screen design. The key is that the decision is intentional and approved before the plants are ordered.
What Arboras provides with a proposed substitution
We check the plants, sizes, and quantities on a contractor’s schedule against current availability from the McMinnville grower network.
If a specified line is short, we propose the closest available option before the order is released. The contractor reviews the change and approves, adjusts, or removes the line.
Approval before ordering: No plant substitution should move forward without contractor approval.
That process matters because we coordinate entire plant lists, from B&B shade and screening trees to shrubs, grasses, perennials, and groundcover. A change on one line can affect the appearance and spacing of the complete installation.
Questions to ask before approving any plant substitute
Use this checklist before confirming a change:
- Does it serve the same purpose as the specified plant?
- Does it fit the site’s sun, soil, drainage, and space conditions?
- Does its mature height and width work in the intended location?
- Does it change the planting spacing or quantity?
- Does it preserve the project’s privacy, shade, seasonal interest, or focal-point goals?
- Is the quoted size and quantity currently available?
- Does it affect price or delivery timing?
- Has the client, designer, or authorized project lead approved it in writing?
Send Arboras the plant schedule before availability becomes a problem
Send a photo, PDF, or typed plant list with the job city and requested delivery date.
We check each line, propose substitutions when needed, and coordinate delivery to Nashville-area job sites in Davidson, Williamson, Rutherford, Sumner, and Wilson counties.
Email sales@arboras.com or call 615-967-0796. You can also text your list.
One checked quote within one business day. Delivery included.
Browse plants or learn more about our wholesale plant service for Nashville contractors.
Have a plan with these on it?
Send us the list